| Proportional Representation
How would it work?
By Guy Dauncey
1. Under the Mixed Member Proportional system, each voter would
have two votes – a Constituency Vote and a Party Vote. With your
Constituency vote, you would vote for the candidate you wanted
as your MLA. With your Party vote, you would vote for the party
you want to see represented in the Legislature.
2. The Legislative Assembly would have 68 seats, instead of 79.
There would be 34 constituency seats, following the 34 federal
riding boundaries, and 34 Party List seats, making administration
easier, and reducing the cost of running the Legislature. If the
number of federal seats increases, the seats in the Legislature
would increase by double that amount.
3. There would be 34 Constituency MLAs, and 34 Party MLAs. The
Constituency MLAs would represent the constituencies, and the
Party MLAs would be chosen from a ranked list of candidates which
each party would submit before the election, prepared in whatever
it chose. Usually the party leader and the party’s most respected
constituency candidates would head the party lists. The lists
would be well advertised, and subject to public and media scrutiny.
Based on experience elsewhere, parties would try to balance their
candidates in terms of male-female, rural-urban, and minorities
representation. Candidates could run for both Constituency and
Party Seats.
4. The Party List would be used to create proportional representation.
In an election, when the votes had been counted, the chief electoral
officer would examine the proportion of the Party vote that each
party won, compare it to their number of Constituency MLAs, and
make up the difference from the Party Lists. If the Purple Party
won 18% of the Party vote, they would be entitled to 18% of the
68 seats (12 MLAs). If they won 3 Constituency MLAs, they would
receive 9 MLAs from their Party list. Party MLAs would also represent
their constituents, and have offices in their home constituencies.
There would be no distinction between Constituency and Party MLAs
in the Legislative Assembly.
5. If a party won more Constituency MLAs than warranted by its
share of the Party vote, it would keep the seats it won, and the
other parties would receive a smaller number of Party seats.
6. Parties must win 5% of the Party vote, or one Constituency
seat, and run candidates in at least 4 of the 34 constituencies
to be eligible for Party seats. This is similar to the system
in New Zealand and Germany. 7. Between elections, Party lists
could not be added to. If a list from the previous election was
exhausted and there was no one to fill a vacant Party seat, it
would remain vacant until the next election.
|